| Tallinger | Taylor | Brindle | Williams |
Race/ Ethnicity | White | Black | White | Black |
Language | English | English | English | English |
Religion | Catholic or Protestant | Catholic or Protestant | Catholic or Protestant | Catholic or Protestant |
Economics/ Employ. | Each is a consultant – Mr. T works in fundraising & Mrs. T in personnel Combined annual income $175,000 – flexible hours but work evenings & weekends; also includes often traveling. Money never mentioned in front of the kids. Experiencing financial problems – firm not paying out on time leads to $7000 penalties in mortgage | - Mr. T currently unemployed – formally worked for social services including counseling for drug related issues. - he doesn’t pay child support Ms. T works as a secretary - has a car that works occasionally - annual income $20,000 - money is an issue and spoken about in this household often | - Currently Unemployed and hopes to return to work once Melmel starts school (18 months old) - collects food stamps and cash stipends - Mr. B pays the Dept. of Human Services child support to offset the public assistance payment to the family - money is often spoken about in front of the children | - Mrs. W is a high-level manager in a major corporation: overnight trip at least once a month - Mr. W is a trial lawyer in a small firm handling medical malpractice cases - preparing the cases keeps him busy from 5am to midnight for two weeks each month; otherwise he works until 6pm - combined annual income is over $200,000 - they rarely discuss money with Alexander |
Housing | 42 yr. Old two story house on a cul-de-sac/ Big green lawns – swimming pool | Rented 4 bedroom, three story house | - Small rundown 3 bedroom apt - not well maintained: leaky ceiling and many roaches - often the washers and dryers don’t work | - A 6 bedroom, large, old stone house with an expansive porch and a sweeping lawn - it is immaculately kept and expensively furnished |
Geography | Quiet suburb near major northeastern city | Pretty quiet neighborhood with crime everywhere – father lives in an apt. in the city “the ghetto” | White working-class neighborhood that is dominated by small houses | Quiet street in a middle-class white neighborhood in a major northeastern city |
Food | Often eat out at fast food restaurants like Taco Bell after practices –meals together determined by the boy’s activ. | Weekly go out for fast food and once a month go to a restaurant such as Sizzler | Nearest grocery store is a 20 min bus ride away - relies on food stamps: food is in short supply | - Spend most of their time in the kitchen - eats pretty well: fruits and vegetables - food is not an issue |
Norms/ Values | Concerted Cultivation plays a huge role in development – Garrett’s scheduled activities define the families pace of life – extended family members not a large part of this family’s organization except for holidays. | Natural Development – mother & father separated - append Miss to all female adult names - sister Anisha (13) cares for Tyrec after school while the mother is still working - plays with children of all ages outside of the house and develops skills in mediation, conflict management, personal responsibility, and strategizing | Natural Development – don’t feel that the kids’ leisure time is of any real importance - Katie’s father is inconsistently involved in her life -All of her siblings are of different fathers - very independent: fixes herself soup after school and joined a school choir - is concerned she is fat – she isn’t - was sexually molested in the first grade - cousin is Katie’s best friend - extended family is very much a part of Katie’s life and often stays with her grandmother | Concerted Cultivation plays a huge role in development – Especially language and its use towards entitlement - By the time weekends come the family is exhausted but continue for the benefits to Alexander - Alexander is bored without structured activities – interacts with boys his age only through activities - consider themselves close to extended family (live far away) by talking via telephone and visiting 3 to 4 times a year |
Politics | N/A | Mr. T has opinions on many issues, including the state of the world, which he offers freely to anyone who will listen | N/A | - Concerned about the impact of race on Alexander: “it isn’t going to define who he is.” |
Relationship w/ Local Geography | N/A | - Where Mr. T lives is the “ghetto” - utilizes the shops in the white neighborhood close by | - Katie takes the bus to Grandma’s by herself (20 min ride) | -the only black family in the white neighborhood in which they live |
Formal Education – Level + Type | Both hold bachelor’s degrees from same Ivy League College & were involved in sports | Mr. T dropped out of school when he was young + reading is difficult for him. Ms. T is a high school graduate | Ms. B earned her GED | - Mrs. W has a master’s degree in liberal arts from an elite college - Mr. W earned his J.D. degree from a well-regarded private university |
Structures/ Institutions | Baseball, Piano lesson, International Soccer, Forest Soccer, Swim Team, Saxophone, Cub Scouts + tryouts and tournaments. | Summer day camp, Sunday School, + Vacation bible School for the summer + football | After school choir | School activities, church life, soccer games, choir, piano, + baseball |
Class | Middle-Class | Working-Class | Working-Class/Poor | Middle-Class |
| McAllister | Marshall | Handlon | Driver |
Race/ Ethnicity | Black | Black | White | White |
Language | English | English | English | English |
Religion | Catholic or Protestant | Catholic or Protestant | Catholic or Protestant | Catholic or Protestant |
Economics/ Employ. | - Currently unemployed and receives public assistance, but hopes to work again - Do not own a car - Do not have a telephone -Receives aid from Aid to Families with Dependent Children - Receives food stamps - has a medical card for doctor visits | - Mrs. M is employed full time in the computer industry: telecommunicates once a week and the other days travels fifty miles round trip. - Mr. M is employed as a civil servant: he works nights 6 days a week, is not required to travel and leaves at 2:30am. - Combined income $100,000 per, but worries about money because of lack of job security in the computer industry: they have down-sized in recent years | - Mr. H works as a credit manager in a major corporation - Mrs. H is employed as a secretary. She works 30 hours per week. - family income of $85,000-$95,000 a year and take much of their middle class status for granted: they have many electronics and each adult has a car. | - Ms. D works as a secretary for fourteen years - Annual income between $15,000-$25,000 + weekend job as a waitress Mr. D passed away – never paid child support - Mr. Fallon is in the flooring business and earns $20,000 working every other weekend and many holidays - money is an issues that is talked about frequently: sometimes for hours - in order to pay for Wendy’s tutor, Ms. D has to walk to work instead of the bus |
Housing | Lower Richmond public housing project – 2 story apt. - Refrigerator is broken - Roaches a constant problem - Sidewalks are littered with glass, paper, and wrappers. | 4 Bedroom house on a circular street lined with recently built, two story suburban homes with a market value of $200,000 - small front yard - driveway with a basketball hoop - large backyard | 4 Bedroom, two story red brick house worth $245,000 in a homogenous suburban neighborhood | Rented 3 Bedroom two-story brick house which is larger than most homes of working class families. -Rent is $650 a month |
Geography | Off of a busy street, a few blocks from a small business area - Residents are all African American along with the surrounding area: there is a white working-class neighborhood within walking distance - Housing project is considered a dangerous area | Well-to-do racially integrated, suburban neighborhood: transitional area - bordered with a central city with one side consisting of an all-black middle class neighborhood and a predominantly white-neighborhood on the other side | White suburban neighborhood | White urban working class neighborhood not a car’s drive away from surrounding black communities |
Food | Food is often in short supply - they must ask permission before eating something - on special occasions food may be plentiful, but more often, there is not enough to go around | N/A | Eat meals together | Food is in ample supply and children often ask for items when they go to the store |
Norms/ Values | Natural Development Television is always on – plays sports outside “doing the same thing over and over is fun.” - Parents separated, but father buys pizza every Friday night and sometimes sleeps on the couch - 5 to 7 people sleep - children sleep in different beds on different nights | Concerted Cultivation plays a large part in development - Mother speaks out and intervenes in Stacy’s institutional life - Always looks to put the blame on someone else: the teachers need to adjust to Stacy’s learning style – the gymnastics instructor is at fault… - Feels that there is an underlying race issue to the circumstances of her child’s encounters, but proceeds cautiously until she has enough evidence – Art the bus driver. | Concerted Cultivation a large part of Melanie’s development: mother worries that if Melanie is not involved in organized activities, they will have no one to play with after school or during breaks – but also believes that children should have free unstructured time. - Misses school frequently - feels Melanie has a lot of homework; it’s too hard and helps her every night for 2-3 hours - Mother fails to bring Melanie to school on time or comply with the school bureaucratic rules of the school. - Mother is in denial of Melanie’s learning problem and the fact that her missing school influences her learning and grades - intervenes awkwardly in Melanie’s schooling | Natural Development: extended family plays a major role in Wendy’s life - family events are very important to them - her two best friends are her cousins - Wendy enjoys the little things of life: loves to play outside and watch the lightning - Plays with all white girls |
Politics | N/A | - Mrs. M believes that intervening in Stacy’s “world” will give her the best opportunities instead of Stacy working to attain whatever she seeks. Ex. The gymnastics instructor confrontation – moving Stacy to a new level, IQ test & class, Girl Scouts. - Believes their race influences the way they are treated: Gymnastics instructor & Art, the Bus Driver | N/A | N/A |
Relationship w/ Local Geography | N/A | N/A | N/A | - neighborhood is safe enough to walk to local stores, Wendy’s dance lessons and religious instruction |
Formal Education – Level + Type | High School Graduate? - was a high school athlete | - Mrs. M is a college graduate and holds a masters degree in Math. The black sorority she pledged for is still a big part of her life. - Mr. M was active in his fraternity during his undergraduate years. | - Mrs. H completed 2 years of junior college - Mr. H has an M.A. in credit and financial management | Ms. D has a high school diploma - Mr. Fallon is a high school graduate |
Structures/ Institutions | N/A | Church: Sunday school, youth choir, + junior ushers. A series of different summer camps, basketball, gymnastics, horseback riding, piano lessons | - Every Sunday Church service, Sunday school and youth choir practice - piano lessons, Girl Scouts: Cookies for the homeless” school holiday performance + special holiday performances for her church Christmas show. –swim team | CCD and dance lessons |
Class | Working-Class/poor | Middle-Class | Middle-Class | Working-Class |
| Yanelli |
Race/ Ethnicity | White |
Language | English |
Religion | Catholic or Protestant |
Economics/ Employ. | - Mrs. Y works off the books cleaning houses for $12 - Mr. Y is a house painter - they do not have health insurance - were once on welfare - do not have a checking account - Money is always tight |
Housing | Small 2 bedroom brick house: open the front door right to the curb |
Geography | White working class neighborhood with narrow streets and narrow houses All black neighborhood a few blocks away |
Food | |
Norms/ Values | Natural Development: Billy plays with other children from the neighborhood, watched television and goes with his mother to run errands. -He is often in trouble at school - The Y’s are close to their extended family - The family uses directives to get their point across: Billy Shower, Billy Move- gets hit with a leather belt -feel school was a threatening force |
Politics | N/A |
Relationship w/ Local Geography | N/A |
Formal Education – Level + Type | Both parents dropped out of high school |
Structures/ Institutions | Baseball and Mr. Y is Billy’s coach |
Class | Working Class |
| |
No comments:
Post a Comment